Home health star ratings explained
What the CMS Quality of Patient Care and patient survey star ratings measure, how to read the percentages on each profile, and the limits of the numbers.
Every agency profile on Home Health Stars shows numbers Medicare publishes about that agency. They are useful, but only if you know what they are and are not saying. This guide walks through each one. It reports CMS data as published and does not rate agencies itself.
Two different star ratings
CMS publishes two separate ratings for home health agencies, and they answer different questions.
- Quality of Patient Care star rating. Based on OASIS assessments (the standard patient assessments agencies file) and Medicare claims. It is updated quarterly.
- Patient survey star rating. Based on the Home Health CAHPS survey, in which patients rate their experience. Also updated quarterly.
This site shows the Quality of Patient Care rating, which is the one used to order agencies within a city. An agency can do well on one and poorly on the other, so it is worth looking at both on Medicare Care Compare.
What goes into the quality rating
According to CMS, the quality rating uses seven measures:
- Timely initiation of care
- Improvement in ambulation (walking)
- Improvement in bed transferring
- Improvement in bathing
- Improvement in shortness of breath
- Improvement in management of oral medications
- Potentially preventable hospitalizations during the home health stay
The patient survey rating covers four areas: care of patients, communication between providers and patients, specific care issues, and the overall rating of care.
Reading the percentages on a profile
- Started care on time. How often the first visit happened promptly. Higher is better.
- Improved at walking, bathing, breathing and so on. Among patients who had room to improve, the share who did. Higher is better.
- Hospital stays during home health. Where shown, lower is better.
Compare agencies in the same city, not against 100%. A one- or two-point gap is usually too small to mean anything. A large gap deserves a question on the phone. For example (an illustration, not real data): if one agency started care on time for 98 of every 100 patients and another for 80, you would ask the second what causes the delays.
When there is no rating
CMS requires a minimum amount of data. For the quality rating, an agency needs at least 20 complete quality episodes or home health stays and data on at least 5 of the 7 measures. For the survey rating, it needs 40 or more completed surveys over four quarters. New and small agencies often have no rating. "Not enough data" is not a bad sign. It is a reason to ask more questions, such as how long the agency has operated and who the clinical manager is.
Limits of the numbers
- They lag. Measures cover past periods, so a recent staffing change will not show yet.
- Case mix. Agencies that serve sicker patients can post lower improvement rates.
- Agency-wide. A rating describes the whole agency, not the particular nurse or therapist who will visit you.
- Not everything is measured. Courtesy, reliability and communication show up only partly, mostly in the survey rating.
Using the stars well
Use the ratings to narrow a list to two or three agencies, then call them with the questions in our choosing guide. If you have a Medicare Advantage plan, start with the plan's network list. Data come from the CMS file 6jpm-sxkc, and the official explanation is on Medicare Care Compare. This is general information, not medical advice.
A worked example of comparing two profiles
Imagine two agencies in the same city (this is an illustration, not real data). Agency A has a higher star rating but a lower share of patients who got better at bathing. Agency B has a lower rating but starts care on time more often. Which matters more depends on your situation. If your parent is coming home from a hip replacement and needs therapy to start within two days, on-time starts and walking improvement matter most. If the main goal is regaining independence with bathing, look at that measure instead.
The overall stars are a summary. The individual lines tell you which strengths the agency has. Look at the measures that match the doctor's goals for the patient.
Questions the numbers cannot answer
- Will the same clinician come each visit?
- How quickly does the office call back?
- Is there a nurse available at night for urgent questions?
- How does the agency work with the patient's own doctor?
Ask these on the phone. The answers, together with the published data, give a fuller picture than either alone.
Where else to look
Stars are one input among several. Medicare Care Compare shows the same CMS data in its own format. Your state health department may publish inspection results for home health agencies, usually called surveys, and you can ask the agency for its most recent one. Your own doctor, the hospital's discharge planner and friends who have used a local agency can tell you things no dataset can, such as which agencies answer the phone at night. None of these replaces the others; use them together.
Frequently confused points
- Stars are relative. CMS compares agencies with each other, so a middle rating does not mean poor care. It means the agency's measures fall in the middle of the pack.
- A rating is not an endorsement. This site does not recommend any agency. We show the CMS number so you can ask better questions.
- Ratings change. Because CMS updates quarterly, an agency's stars can move up or down. Check the date on the data before you rely on it.
- Percentages need patients. A percentage from a small number of patients can swing widely. If an agency's figure looks extreme, ask how many patients it covers.
If something on a profile looks wrong, tell us, but note that we can only repeat what CMS publishes. Errors in the underlying data are corrected by the agency and CMS.
General information only, current as of the date above. The information on Home Health Stars is not medical advice and does not replace a doctor, nurse, discharge planner or other qualified professional. Do not use it to make decisions about diagnosis or treatment. If you have a medical emergency, call 911. Rules and programs change; check the official sources linked in this guide.